BSG is bad for my marriage...
Oct. 14th, 2006 01:20 amWell, actually my massive annoyance with BSG is bad for my marriage.
You see, BSG annoys me and I rant about it at my poor husband. Since BSG doesn't annoy him, it ends up causing stressful... discussions in which we come close to sounding like we're arguing. It's a tad stressful and completely unfair to poor Wil.
But I just can't help it. It just annoys me so damn much.
That's not exactly true. The cheap, theatrical writing that they occasionally stick in BSG annoys me. In a show that has many legitimately tense and moving moments, it too often settles for slight of hand and time manipulation to build contrived suspense -- often at the expense of what could have been truly suspenseful scenes in their own right.
The sheer manipulation of it irritates me to the point of being unable to enjoy the scene. It's so obviously a manipulation -- it's like watching the old serialized cliff hangers, where they stick on a completely pointless life-threatening situation at the end of a part only to have the situation completely resolved and rendered moot in the next ten minutes of story. The worst part is, the artificial construct of it makes the actual, natural ending points of the scene less powerful.
Don't get me wrong, I like the show but I want to love the show. Maybe I'm expecting too much from it. After all I love 24 and that's all about artificial constructs. Not only I can live with that, but I look forward to them. It doesn't bother me because that's what 24 is. It's not what I want BSG to be, though. *sigh* ( Wherein I expound on my (possibly unreasonable) expectations of BSG )
If you want to make a point in your writing, make it an argument, not a sermon. More importantly, don't bring up volatile, morally complicated issues without being sure to recognize that's it is a volatile, morally complicated issue.
You see, BSG annoys me and I rant about it at my poor husband. Since BSG doesn't annoy him, it ends up causing stressful... discussions in which we come close to sounding like we're arguing. It's a tad stressful and completely unfair to poor Wil.
But I just can't help it. It just annoys me so damn much.
That's not exactly true. The cheap, theatrical writing that they occasionally stick in BSG annoys me. In a show that has many legitimately tense and moving moments, it too often settles for slight of hand and time manipulation to build contrived suspense -- often at the expense of what could have been truly suspenseful scenes in their own right.
The sheer manipulation of it irritates me to the point of being unable to enjoy the scene. It's so obviously a manipulation -- it's like watching the old serialized cliff hangers, where they stick on a completely pointless life-threatening situation at the end of a part only to have the situation completely resolved and rendered moot in the next ten minutes of story. The worst part is, the artificial construct of it makes the actual, natural ending points of the scene less powerful.
Don't get me wrong, I like the show but I want to love the show. Maybe I'm expecting too much from it. After all I love 24 and that's all about artificial constructs. Not only I can live with that, but I look forward to them. It doesn't bother me because that's what 24 is. It's not what I want BSG to be, though. *sigh* ( Wherein I expound on my (possibly unreasonable) expectations of BSG )
If you want to make a point in your writing, make it an argument, not a sermon. More importantly, don't bring up volatile, morally complicated issues without being sure to recognize that's it is a volatile, morally complicated issue.